Remi Vespa suggested an interesting topic in his 10 reasons NOT to outsource; while I agree with most of the points he made, my top 10 would be somewhat different:
1. No reasons to outsource. Let me clear a suspected circular reference here: take a look at my earlier posts Top reasons for outsourcing and My reasons to outsource; if your reasons for outsourcing are not listed there and more so after some reading and thinking appear to be superficial, they probably are.
2. Personal. If you do not believe in outsourcing, if it could present a clear and present danger to your career, or outsourcing is likely to affect your life in some tangible negative manner (take a look at Offshore Risks: Team and Personal Impacts for some hints) stay away from offshoring as far as you can.
3. No executive support / sponsorship, no organizational / team support. If you running and uphill battle in your organization – your execs do not believe outsourcing is beneficial for the organization, if getting appropriate funds is questionable, if your team doesn’t support you. Well, maybe you are agent of change, yet still, you need to pick your battles.
4. Low risk tolerance. Your organization / your boss / yourself do not tolerate risk well and have high penalties for mistakes. Trying offshoring in environment like that is a very risky proposition.
5. No appropriate opportunity. There is always a risk in applying such a powerful yet delicate weapon as outsourcing to tasks that are not made for it. And there is not much use of trying to fit square pegs in round holes.
6. No offshore-ready management resources. If you and your management team doesn’t have any experience with outsourcing you might be better off without it unless you are mentally and financially ready to sustain a lot of pain.
7. No processes. If your organization is process free or still straggling to achieve CMM1 inviting outsourcing is likely to cost you an arm and a leg, so stay away from offshore, unless of course you’ve got spares.
8. You need to cut costs, now. Properly handled and with a bit of luck offshoring is likely to show some cost savings, yet as they say it takes money to make money. Your need to invest before you realize the savings. So if your need to immediately make up for the luck of sales or some other reasons behind a deep dive in P&L you might look for some other cost saving techniques.
9. No sufficient runway for taking off. Getting offshore engagement off the ground and getting it to the point it starts delivering value is not a trivial exercise. Do not expect immediate gratifications nor even start on that route if you have not enough runway (funds, time and energy), there is no glory in crash-landing.
10. No runway to land. No matter how skillful you are, how well financed is the project, how perfectly it is executed there is still a chance that your offshoring engagement fails. If that failure is likely to cause substantial damage, if there is no way you can safely terminate the engagement think twice before starting it.
Of course many of these reasons and the items listed in Remi’s post can be dealt with, risks mitigated, and challenges addressed. Nevertheless you should not take any of them lightly and do not move forward with your outsourcing initiative till you take the last item off your Top Reasons NOT to Outsource list.